August 31, 2017

Mrs. Dalloway's Moving Castle

In reading Mrs. Dalloway, I keep getting imagery of Howl's Moving Castle (the Miyazaki movie). For those unfamiliar with it, the story comes from a 1986 book by Diana Wynne Jones. The main story involves magic, sorcerers, and curse-breaking. However, the points and ideas that stuck out to me as similar to Mrs. Dalloway's involved the setting and a few of the characters.
Sophie works in a hat-shop in a town called Market Chipping, in the fantasy world of Ingary. She is turned into an old woman by an evil witch until she can break her curse. However, the somewhat unlucky, dull Sophie realizes that she was kind of an old woman in personality already, and it's sort of her natural state. She sets off to find a new place in the world, and stumbles upon the wizard Howl.

The whole idea of an old woman who simultaneously feels young yet old is really epitomized here: she's literally both at once. Much like Clarissa, she spends a lot of time thinking about her "past" and when she was younger (technically last week, but) and thinks she isn't beautiful at all. Sophie really just seems very Clarissa-like in her manner, always getting lost in thoughts and not thinking of herself as important at all. Also like Clarissa, she is strong-willed, kind, and considerate, if a little impulsive. 
Some of the opening scenes in Dalloway really remind me of the images in Howl's...
Mostly the images of a prim, straight-backed woman taking a walk in a crowded city. Miyazaki's admittedly more steampunk machines and automobiles still show lot of similarities to Woolf's realism.
Here we have Sophie's sister in the story, Lettie. She reminds me a lot of Lucrezia as she takes care of Sophie, who, as we see, is rather absent-minded and apathetic, much like Septimus is, outwardly. 

 Lucrezia and Clarissa don't know each other in Mrs.  Dalloway, but if they did, I feel like it would be a lot like that right-hand gif. That interaction definitely happens between Rezia and Septimus several times throughout the book.


Now for the big similarity I see- setting. I've alluded to this a few times, but the time and place setting of both stories are similar.  The land of Ingary resembles a steampunky, fantasy early 20th century London.We first meet Sophie in Market Chipping, a smaller town full of hat shops, flower shops, and people who buy frivolous things from them. This world differs from June 1923 in that Ingary is not a post-war setting; instead it is currently at war with Strangia and High Norland, neighboring countries. Its capital is Kingsbury, and Sophie spends some time there as well. Kingsbury especially reminds me of Clarissa's London, with huge towers and orderly hustle and bustle.


this picture formatting is making me want to kill someone



































I love the visuals of people taking strolls past this big statue: it really evokes those images that Peter, Rezia, and Septimus see in Regent's Park (in p. 69-71) of all these calm, dignified people going about their day.






(There's also a port scene which I vaguely remember, maybe from at Bourton? I got a strong mental image of this shot from Howl's Moving Castle:
)

I wonder if Miyazaki or his art staff had read Dalloway, or if 1920s England was such an iconic era that it's so instantly recognizable.

I also thought about making comparisons between Howl and Peter, but I'll save that slightly more sticky comparison for other posts and/or other commenters.




3 comments:

  1. It's so cool that while reading Mrs. Dalloway you were able to formulate this connection to Howl's Moving Castle. I've never seen the movie but just from reading your post I can see the similarities between them. The pictures that you included really helped me to visualize your argument. While looking at them I could definitely imagine Clarissa looking out on the water or walking around the park. Your question of whether Miyazaki has read Mrs. Dalloway or not is intriguing to me. It is possible that the culture of England at this time is so iconic that two artists could make two products that are so different centered around the themes. I want to watch this movie myself while thinking of Mrs. Dalloway to see if there are more connections I could find, and see if there any huge differences.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I absolutely adore the Studio Ghibli movies and I found this blog post to be a very fun read and an incredibly well though out and represented connection. I would love to see a Studio Ghibli Mrs. Dalloway but I think it might be a exceptionally heavy subject for their kid oriented audiance :(

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is the most unique post I have read yet and I love Howl's Moving Castle. The imagery is very specialized in this movie, and I'm jealous that you had such strong visuals to guide you throughout Mrs. Dalloway. It's bizarre how so drastically different entertainment mediums can intersect. It is clear you have an eye for art :)

    ReplyDelete